Is value-based care a ‘failed’ experiment? Some health system CEOs say so
Value-based care arrangements — agreements where payers reward providers for keeping care high quality and low cost — are not making healthcare more affordable, two health system CEOs said at a Wisconsin Health News event this week.
Other CEOs on the panel called for tailoring payment models to specific populations and said success will depend on the details.
Edited excerpts from the discussion are below.
Watch the event on WisconsinEye.
WHN: What can be done about healthcare costs?
UW Health CEO Dr. Alan Kaplan: Let’s talk about the uninsured. If (the enhanced Affordable Care Act) subsidies go away, not only will families not be able to afford healthcare, but someone else has got to pick up the tab. Somehow, the hospitals and physicians have to stay in business. They still have to pay their staff. They still have to pay pharmaceutical costs, and so forth. That goes on to businesses. There will be only so much tolerance for that. I think we’re kind of hitting that limit.
As far as value-based care, well, I think the concept’s correct. (Emplify Health CEO Dr. Scott Rathgaber) and I have talked about this in the past. We both believe in it. We’re both co-owners in an insurance plan and try to drive higher quality and lower costs.
The truth is, I believe, it’s a failed national experiment. The payment policies don’t support it … You can cut as much as you want out of unnecessary care. You can’t outpace inflation. So I don’t think the answer is value-based care.
I do think that government intervention and ACA subsidies are going to be very important for affordability. But, unfortunately, I only see healthcare costs escalating over the next foreseeable future.
WHN: Would you agree that value-based care is a failed experiment?
Rathgaber: I do agree. You go back to the data. It really hasn’t caused a lot of improvement in cost. We continue to have high quality care, which is great. But I’m more and more suspicious of value-based care contracts. Are they really trying to drive value? Or are they trying to find a way to kind of decrease what I ultimately get paid, to be honest with you?
At Emplify Health, we’re pretty good at doing value-based contracts. The (accountable care organization) at Bellin Health has been a top performer — number one or two in the country — as far as bringing savings back to Medicare for a number of years. We’re actually pretty good at it. We do have a lot of value-based contracts that we get payment from. But I think it’s not a solution that has shown to be successful in what it’s trying to do. Therefore, I’m starting to shy away from some of that perspective.
And then you say, ‘Well, then what else are you going to do?’ I do believe that we need to work on the payment model. Because whatever payment model, it drives how everybody behaves. I think about a capitated sort of payment model, where you give me a certain amount of money to take care of a certain population, understanding what their risk is, and then I go after it. And then I can start to invest in population health to bring in better health for folks. But if you’re just doing it by value and by some sort of formula, which everybody has a different formula for every contract — so then I have an army of people watching, ‘Well, how are we doing on each one of these formulas?’ — it’s not consistent, and it’s actually not efficient.
So I think the answer is to change the payment model into more of a global payment. Then I’m on the hook to make sure I take care of those patients in an efficient way, and that’s where my incentive is to try to keep people healthy. So that’s part of the solution. And we can talk about how other competitors don’t have to fund a hospital, (an intensive care unit), behavioral health and some of those things. We want to make sure we have a level playing field with those who want to also be in the space. I’m not against them. I just want to make sure I have a level playing field.
WHN: Would you support a shift to a more globally capitated payment system?
Ascension Wisconsin CEO Daniel Jackson: I’m not opposed to it. I think the specificity is around who you’re taking care of, so it’s not one-size-fits-all. So the care model should be formulated to care for a specific community or who you’re taking care of. There are multiple models that can be effective.
WHN: Vernon Health in Viroqua is collaborating with nine other independent rural hospitals to work with insurers on value-based care. What do you think?
CEO David Hartberg: Like anything that comes out, you learn a lot about what works and doesn’t work. I think that a number of the people in the Wisconsin High Value Network have been in ACOs and have learned a little bit about some things that have worked for them and haven’t worked for them.
I like the idea in this conversation about who we’re serving. Vernon Health is one of those hospitals that continues to provide obstetrical care in the face of many hospitals closing. We’re providing behavioral healthcare. I think that does speak a little bit to what you’re trying to be for your community. And those that have narrowed their list down for a multitude of reasons and said, ‘We’re only going to do this,’ I look at that and say, “OK, that’s not an even playing field.’
The hard part with value-based care and capitation is that I need a couple more words attached to those because otherwise those are pretty global comments. The devil’s in the details of what those are.
We continue to try to learn. The Wisconsin High Value Network, as it’s just forming, is trying to have some of those conversations about, ‘What are the learnings so far? What things failed? What things did well? What can be some future iterations?’
What we’re currently doing is not going to work long term. I think you’ve heard that from all four of us. It’s going to get more and more challenging. So where do we move next? What can we put at risk? Vernon Health has got to care for its area of the Driftless. It’s got to be really careful about what risks it’s willing to take. No one else is running into Viroqua to say, ‘I’d really love to run an emergency room here.’ So we’ve got to be there, and we’ve got to be there to deliver babies and provide behavioral health services and all of the things that we’re doing. We know we’ve got to be different, like everybody else, and we’ll try to see how we navigate that going forward.