Wisconsin Supreme Court backs conversion therapy ban 

Wisconsin Supreme Court backs conversion therapy ban 

The Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that a legislative committee doesn’t have the power to block a ban on the discredited practice of conversion therapy, in a decision that curtails legislators’ ability to halt administrative rules.

The state rule blocking marriage and family therapists, professional counselors and social workers from attempting to change LGBTQ+ clients’ sexual orientation and gender identities took effect in April 2024, after legislators blocked it multiple times.

Healthcare providers say conversion therapy lacks evidence and harms patients. The American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry says it should not be part of mental healthcare.

In an opinion joined by the court’s three other liberal justices, Chief Justice Jill Karofsky wrote that the Republican-controlled Joint Committee for Review of Administrative Rules halted the rule for about three years, impeding the state board that oversees the professions from “establishing the licensure standards it is statutorily entrusted to create.”

While the rule is in effect now, the committee, under a state statute challenged by Gov. Tony Evers, has “the authority to suspend this rule again, in perpetuity,” Karofsky wrote.

The 4-3 ruling in favor of Evers declared the committee doesn’t have the power to block state administrative rules.

Conservative Justice Brian Hagedorn wrote an opinion that concurs and dissents from the decision. He favored a narrow ruling, applying just to the challenged rules. Since the conversion therapy ban is already in effect, and a ruling from the court would have no legal effect, he argued the challenge to the committee’s actions is “moot.”

Conservative Justices Annette Ziegler and Rebecca Bradley filed separate dissenting opinions. Ziegler wrote that the court’s ruling creates “a grave constitutional imbalance” by confining legislative powers, while not doing so for the executive branch.

“Obtaining preferred results appears more important than the rule of law,” she wrote.

In February 2020, Evers approved the conversion therapy ban. In June 2020, the committee objected, halting the rule’s implementation until December 2022.

The ban then went into effect for about six weeks, until the committee acted to suspend it. The rule took effect in April 2024, after the Legislature failed to pass a bill to permanently suspend it.

Evers sued Republican legislative leaders in 2023, alleging the ban’s suspension, as well as other actions by legislators, violated the state’s constitution. The Wisconsin Supreme Court initially took up part of the case dealing with conservation projects and heard arguments on the portion tied to the ban on conversion therapy in January.

The governor said the decision “ensures that no small group of lawmakers has the sole power to stymie the work of state government and go unchecked.”

“This is an incredibly important decision that will ensure state government can do our important work efficiently and effectively,” Evers said.

Assembly Speaker Robin Vos, R-Rochester, said the decision upends decades of case law that “upheld the constitutionality of the legislative rules committee to serve as a legitimate check on the powers of the governor and the overreach of the bureaucracy.”

“Administrative rules touch many facets of our lives, such as business regulations, license renewals, building projects, wetland mitigation and more,” he said in a statement. “The absence of oversight from elected representatives grows government and allows unelected bureaucrats to increase red-tape behind closed doors.”

This article first appeared in the Wisconsin Health News daily email newsletter. Sign up for your free trial here.

Pin It on Pinterest